I take a look at the all National Signing Day (NSD) classes from 2006 - 2010 and then chose the players who actually performed the best 5 years removed from the end of that era based on their Rivals Star.
Only 6 Players from the NSD team made the Performance team.
All National Signing Day Team
QB - Stephen Garcia (4)
RB - Marcus Lattimore (5)
RB - Jarvis Giles (4)
WR - Alshon Jeffery (4) Jason Barnes (4)
WR - Lamar Scruggs (4) Dion Lecorn (4)
TE - Weslye Suanders (4)
OT - Hutch Eckerson (4)
OT - Kevin Young (4)
OG - Garret Anderson (4)
OG - AJ Cann (4)
OL - Quinton Richardson (4)
DT - Kendrick Ellis (4)
DT - Kelcy Quarles (4)
DE - Chris Matthews (4)
DE - Chaz Sutton (4)
LB - Toquavius Gilchrist (4)
LB - Tony Straughter (4)
LB - DeVonte Holloman (4)
S - Chris Culliver (5 - WR)
S - Akeem Auguste (4)
CB - Stephon Gilmore (4)
CB - Charles Whitlock (4)
All Performance Team
QB - Connor Shaw (3)
RB - Marcus Lattimore
RB - Patrick DiMarco (2)
WR - Alshon Jeffery
WR - Ace Sanders (4)
TE - Justice Cunningham (2)
OT - Corey Robinson (3)
OT - Hutch Eckerson
OG - Terrance Cambell (3)
OG - Garret Anderson
OL - TJ Johnson (3)
DT - Kelcy Quarles
DT - Travian Robertson (4)
DE - Devin Taylor (3)
DE - Eric Norwood (3)
LB - Shaq Wilson (3)
LB - Jasper Brinkley (3)
LB - Darian Stewart (3)
S - DJ Swearginger (3)
S - Antonio Allen (3)
CB - Captain Munnerlyn (2)
CB - Stephon Gilmore